Should I repair or replace a leaky faucet?

For minor leaks from the spout or handle, repair is usually the most cost-effective option, but if your faucet is over 15 years old or has multiple issues, replacement often makes more financial sense.

Most faucet leaks can be fixed by replacing worn washers, O-rings, or cartridges - repairs that typically cost $20-50 in parts if you're handy with basic tools. A dripping spout usually means a worn washer or seat, while leaks around the handle indicate damaged O-rings or packing. These are straightforward fixes for most homeowners with the right parts and a few basic tools.

However, replacement becomes the better choice when you're dealing with an older faucet (15+ years), corroded internal components, or multiple simultaneous leaks. Older faucets often have discontinued parts that are expensive or impossible to find, and fixing one leak frequently leads to discovering additional problems. If you're already calling a plumber for the repair, the labor cost difference between repair and replacement is often minimal.

In Ottawa's market, a basic faucet repair by a licensed plumber runs $150-300, while faucet replacement typically costs $300-500 including a mid-range fixture. Given Ottawa's hard water conditions, faucets here tend to accumulate mineral buildup faster, which can make older units more prone to recurring issues after repair.

Consider replacement if your faucet has low water pressure (indicating internal buildup), the finish is deteriorating, or you're planning any kitchen or bathroom updates. Modern faucets also offer better water efficiency, which can provide long-term savings on your water bill.

For a straightforward assessment of whether repair or replacement makes sense for your specific situation, a quick consultation with a licensed plumber can save you money in the long run.